Adult care homes and assisted living facilities are two popular long-term care options for seniors who require varying levels of assistance with daily living activities. Understanding the differences between these two options can help families make informed decisions when choosing the most appropriate care setting for their loved ones.
The aging population and an increasing life expectancy have led to a heightened demand for long-term care options that cater to the needs of older adults. These care options help seniors maintain their independence, dignity, and quality of life as they age while receiving the necessary support and assistance.
Adult Care Homes: Smaller Setting and Personal Care
Adult care homes, also known as residential care homes or board and care homes, provide a smaller, more intimate setting for seniors who need assistance with personal care needs.
Adult care homes typically accommodate a limited number of residents, often ranging from 2 to 10 individuals, and offer a family-like atmosphere.
Services Provided in an Adult Care Home
In adult care homes, trained staff provide support with daily living activities such as bathing, dressing, grooming, and toileting. Adult family homes also assist with medication management and offer meal preparation with dietary supervision.
While adult care homes may provide limited health care services, they usually do not have full-time medical staff on-site. Some medical foster homes may provide a higher level of medical care and have highly-trained staff on site.
Adult Care Home Regulation and Licensing
Adult care homes are regulated at the state level, and licensing requirements may vary from state to state. Prospective residents and their families should research and understand the regulations at both the state and county level to ensure the homes being considered to meet the necessary standards.
In states where licensing inspections happen regularly, the results of individual inspections are public knowledge. Check with your local Area Agency on Aging to inquire about inspection results and how to view them.
Adult Family Home Cost and Payment Options
The cost of adult care homes typically depends on the level of care required and the location of the facility. On average, adult care homes cost anywhere from $3,000-$7,000 per month.
Payment options may include private pay, Medicaid, or other state-funded programs.
It is essential to discuss payment plans and options with the adult care home owner/operator to determine the best financial arrangement for your loved one.
Assisted Living Facilities: Larger Setting, Individual Apartment Style Living
Assisted living facilities offer a broader range of services and amenities for seniors who can live semi-independently but may require support for some daily activities.
Assisted living communities usually accommodate a larger number of residents and offer apartment-style living, allowing for greater privacy and independence.
Services Provided in Assisted Living
In addition to personal care assistance, assisted living facilities generally provide medication management, meal services in communal dining areas, social and recreational activities, transportation, and housekeeping services.
Some facilities also offer on-site medical care, allowing residents to access healthcare services without leaving the premises.
Assisted Living Regulation and Licensing
Like adult care homes, assisted living facilities are also regulated at the state, and sometimes county level, with varying requirements by state.
It is crucial for families to research and understand the regulations in their area to ensure they select a facility that meets their loved one’s needs and expectations.
Cost and Payment Options in Assisted Living
The cost of assisted living facilities varies based on location, services provided, and the level of care needed. Payment options may include private pay, long-term care insurance, and limited Medicaid coverage (depending on the state).
Families should discuss payment plans and options with the facility administrator or marketing professional to find the most suitable financial arrangement.
Comparing Adult Care Homes and Assisted Living Facilities
Adult care homes and assisted living have some commonalities in terms of the services they offer but are very different in terms of their size, staffing ratios, and the level of care that can be provided to their residents.
Similarities of Adult Care Homes and Assisted Living Facilities
Both adult care homes and assisted living facilities provide assistance with activities of daily living and offer varying levels of care based on individual needs.
They both offer:
- Assistance with dressing, bathing, grooming, toileting, eating, and transfers
- Activities and socialization- Activities in assisted living may be more robust and varied as they are catering to a larger number of residents and interests
- Medication management is available in both assisted living and adult care homes
- Housekeeping and laundry services are built-in services in both levels of care, the primary difference being how frequently these occur.
- Both assisted living and adult care homes offer safety and supervision to their residents. One of the many benefits of adult care homes is that residents tend to have more oversight because of the smaller size of the facility and higher staff-to-resident ratio.
- Balanced and healthy meals are provided in both settings,
Did you know?
Differences Between Assisted Living Facilities and Adult Care Homes
The primary differences between these two options lie in the size and living environment, the scope of services provided, and cost and payment options.
It is crucial to consider these differences when choosing the most appropriate care setting for an individual.
The differences include:
- While both levels of long-term care offer assistance with activities of daily living, the amount of assistance they provide varies widely. For example, in assisted living, help with feeding during mealtime is generally not offered. In an adult care home, caregivers are able to feed residents who can not feed themselves. Assisted living tends to be a better fit for seniors who require less hands-on care and can maintain a certain level of independence.
- Meals are provided in both levels of care, but in an adult care home, it’s much easier for them to cater to residents’ specific food and dietary preferences due to the small number of residents. In assisted living, it can be difficult to please individual requests when they are cooking food for large numbers of people. Assisted living communities generally have a set menu with multiple daily meal options.
- Adult care homes are generally smaller, often housing between 2-10 residents, and are located in residential neighborhoods. They provide a more intimate, home-like environment. Assisted living facilities are typically larger and may house dozens or even hundreds of residents. They often have a more institutional or community-like feel.
- Assisted living facilities generally provide a broader array of amenities and services, such as fitness centers, libraries, beauty salons, and organized social activities. Adult care homes may offer fewer amenities and have a more limited range of services focused primarily on essential care needs. Assisted living facilities will have a designated “Activities Director” to plan and coordinate social events. In an adult care home, planning social events falls to the owner/operator.
- The staffing structure in adult care homes and assisted living facilities is vastly different. Adult care homes have a smaller staff but often foster more personal relationships with residents. Assisted living facilities will have a larger number of staff, including nurses, caregivers, and other support personnel, but may experience higher staff turnover rates.
- Residents in assisted living facilities typically have more autonomy and independence compared to those in adult care homes. They can participate in activities, make decisions about their daily routines, and often have more control over their apartment-style living space.
Choosing the Right Senior Care Option
Assessing individual care needs and preferences is a crucial step in choosing the right long-term care option.
Factors to consider include the level of care required, personal preferences regarding the living environment, financial limitations, and available social and recreational opportunities.
- Touring facilities and evaluating care quality is essential in making an informed decision. Visiting multiple adult care homes and/or assisted living facilities can provide insight into the atmosphere, staff interactions, cleanliness, and overall quality of care.
- Families should consider their budget, payment options, and potential financial assistance programs to determine the most feasible care solution.
- Consider the future resident’s personality, lifestyle, and current and future care needs.
- Consulting with healthcare professionals and family members can provide valuable perspectives and recommendations.
- Involving the entire support network in the decision-making process ensures a well-rounded understanding of the best care option for the individual.
The differences between adult care homes and assisted living facilities lie primarily in their size and living environment, the scope of services provided, and cost and payment options.
Understanding these differences can help families make informed decisions when choosing the most appropriate care setting for their loved ones. The importance of making an informed decision based on individual needs and circumstances must be considered.
By carefully assessing personal requirements, touring facilities, understanding financial implications, and consulting with healthcare professionals and family members, families can ensure they select the most suitable long-term care option for their loved ones.
Frequently Asked Questions
The primary difference lies in the level of care provided and the environment. Adult care homes offer a more intimate, home-like setting with personalized care and attention due to their smaller size. Assisted living facilities provide a broader range of care services and amenities in a larger, more community-like setting, catering to seniors who require less hands-on care and can maintain some level of independence.
In general, adult care homes tend to be less expensive than assisted living facilities. However, costs can vary depending on factors such as location, level of care, and amenities provided. It is essential to compare specific facilities and consider any additional expenses.
Adult care homes are also known as adult family homes, adult foster care homes, board and care homes, room and board homes, and residential care homes. Each state that has this level of care may have a slightly different way of referring to them.
Consider the person’s lifestyle, personality, activity level, and current and future care needs. If they are a social person, an assisted living community may be a better fit. If your loved one has complex medical needs, an adult care home may be best. If they have a dementia diagnosis and are starting to wander, a memory care facility with a secure unit will be the best option to keep them safe.